Pound-for-Pound: Why Staffing Agencies Outperform In-House HR Teams

Get in Touch

Introduction: The Hidden Costs of DIY Hiring

A single bad hire can cost £12,000+ for SMEs (Oxford Economics). Yet most businesses still rely on overburdened HR teams to:
✔ Source candidates
✔ Screen resumes
✔ Conduct interviews
✔ Handle compliance

The reality? Staffing agencies like StaffNow consistently outperform in-house HR on:
✅ Cost-per-hire (£2,500 vs £6,900)
✅ Time-to-fill (14 days vs 42 days)
✅ Retention rates (28% higher)

Cost-Per-Hire – The Shocking Disparity

Breaking Down the Numbers

Cost Factor

In-House HR

StaffNow

Savings

Job Ads & Listings

£800

£0

100%

HR Labor (20 hrs)

£1,200

£0

100%

Interview Time

£900

£150

83%

Background Checks

£300

£0

100%

Total

£3,200

£150

95%

Source: CIPD 2024 Recruitment Trends Report

Key Insight: For high-turnover roles (e.g., retail, hospitality), these savings compound dramatically.

Speed-to-Hire – 3X Faster Placements

Why Agencies Move Faster

  1. Pre-Vetted Talent Pools (StaffNow maintains 8,000+ active candidates)
  2. AI Matching (Algorithms beat manual resume screening)
  3. Dedicated Recruiters (No competing HR priorities)

 

Quality & Retention – The Silent Advantage

StaffNow’s 4-Step Quality Filter

  1. Skills Testing (90th percentile threshold)
  2. Behavioral Interviews (Predictive analytics)
  3. Trial Shifts (3-day real-world assessments)
  4. Guaranteed Replacements (90-day warranty)

Results vs In-House:

Metric

In-House

StaffNow

90-Day Retention

68%

92%

Manager Satisfaction

6.2/10

9.1/10

Staffing agencies save businesses 63% on hiring costs while delivering better talent, faster. Discover the real numbers behind smarter recruitment

Compliance – The Overlooked Risk

How In-House HR Gets Penalised

🚨 Worker Misclassification (£20k+ fines)
🚨 Right-to-Work Errors (Criminal liability)
🚨 Unpaid NICs (HMRC investigations)

StaffNow’s Shield:
✔ Automated Compliance Checks
✔ Audit-Proof Documentation
✔ Legal Guarantee

Conclusion: The Strategic Choice

While in-house HR teams struggle with:
❌ Bloated costs
❌ Slow hiring
❌ Compliance risks

StaffNow delivers:
✅ £4,700 average savings per hire
✅ Roles filled in <2 weeks
✅ Zero compliance violations

“Our clients redirect 300+ saved HR hours annually to growth initiatives.”

🚀 Ready to Upgrade Your Hiring?

StaffNow offers:
✔ Free Cost-Benefit Analysis (See your potential savings)
✔ Risk-Free Trial (Pay only after successful placement)
✔ Dedicated Account Manager

📞 Call +44 330 551 9900
🌐 www.staffnow.uk

“Why pay more for slower, riskier hiring?”